Blog
Red Light Therapy vs Ice
Red Light Therapy vs Ice. If you were to take a sample of doctors and athletic trainers and ask them what therapy they recommend that people use for post-exercise muscle recovery, you are guaranteed to find that a majority will tell you to apply ice. Cryotherapy or icing has long been considered the gold standard for dealing with pretty much any kind of inflammatory process, including the muscle inflammation that occurs following strenuous exercise. Cryotherapy is a therapeutic technique that involves exposing the body or specific areas to extremely cold temperatures, typically using ice packs, cold water immersion, or specialized cryochambers. But research has now clearly shown that when you put icing head-to-head with Red Light Therapy – which uses red and/or near infrared light to influence biology - and look at which one works better to support exercise recovery, Red Light Therapy consistently comes out on top. In 2019, a scientific article was published that reviewed three clinical trials and two animal studies comparing cryotherapy to Red Light Therapy. Each human clinical trial administered both red and near infrared light, while the two animal studies used near infrared light only, and light or cryotherapy were applied following exercise. The outcome for each study was post-exercise muscle recovery. All five studies found that Red Light Therapy was superior to cryotherapy at improving outcomes related to exercise recovery. This included decreased delayed onset muscle soreness and reduced muscle inflammation. The research also showed that in contrast to Red Light Therapy, cryotherapy did nothing to prevent muscle damage from occurring following strenuous exercise, since markers of muscle damage like creatine kinase were only reduced with Red Light Therapy. The superiority of Red Light Therapy over cryotherapy makes perfect sense when you consider the mechanisms of how the two modalities work. In a nutshell, red light therapy stimulates mitochondria to produce energy and modulate oxidative stress, decreasing cellular markers of inflammation. Red Light Therapy also induces cellular changes like increasing the production of growth factors. This is how it can have effects such as decreasing inflammation and healing damaged muscle fibers, and how it can positively influence many aspects of exercise recovery. In contrast, cryotherapy constricts blood vessels and decreases blood flow, which leads to less edema formation (swelling). This might reduce inflammation and decrease pain, but it really does nothing on a cellular level to support healing. In fact, it’s been argued by some experts to do the opposite. Several criticisms of cryotherapy have been raised, including that it only provides temporary relief and does not promote long-term healing. The studies described in this analysis used light that was quite low in intensity. Light intensity refers to the amount of light being delivered by a device. It is also sometimes called irradiance, and it’s usually measured in units called mW/cm2. Red Light Therapy devices on the market vary widely in terms of their intensity. While it’s common to see marketing claims that high intensity products (at upwards of 100mw/cm2) are needed to reap the benefits of Red Light Therapy, this research (and a lot of other studies too), show that this is false. When it comes to using Red Light Therapy for post-exercise muscle recovery, research has clearly shown that more is not better. Instead of high intensity products, it’s best to use a device that delivers both red and near infrared light at a low to moderate intensity. Fringe Red Light Therapy products are great options for post-exercise support, delivering the optimal intensity of light at between 20 and 40mw/cm2. This is like the intensity of the sun. Fringe Red Light Therapy wraps even have the advantage of being portable and cordless, offering the flexibility of immediate use, including on the sideline! So, the next time you have a hard workout, reach for a Red Light Therapy device instead of ice to support muscle healing. And the advantages of Red Light Therapy over cryotherapy extend to healing for other conditions as well. Basically, you can use Red Light Therapy for anything that you would consider using ice for. By using Red Light Therapy instead, you’ll not only decrease pain and inflammation, but you’ll also activate cellular healing mechanisms that will help you to feel better faster. For more information about Fringe light products, go to: https://fringeheals.com/shop-all-products/
Learn more
Top 10 Evidence-Based Uses for Red Light Therapy
Red Light Therapy, also known as photobiomodulation (PBM), may be used to support the health of cells and tissues throughout the body. Defined as the use of red and/or near infrared (NIR) light to influence biology, most modern PBM devices emit both types of light, which have similar effects but penetrate the body to different depths. Red light is visible to the human eye, while infrared light is not, although it can be felt as heat. While early research on PBM used primarily lasers, more recent research has found that LED’s can also be used, which also have the advantage of applying light to a larger area of the body as well as an improved safety profile. The use of LED in red/NIR devices has also greatly reduced the cost of treatment, making it something that can be done in the comfort of one’s own home. There are many mechanisms by which PBM affects the body, with the most well-known being increasing the synthesis of ATP (the energy currency of the cell) through effects on the electron transport chain in the mitochondria. The link between PBM and improved mitochondrial function has been well established. This increased supply of energy can be used to do all kinds of cellular work, including healing, growth, maintenance, and repair. There are thousands of published studies showing the efficacy of PBM for a wide range of health applications, ranging from general support for healthy cells to improving brain function in Alzheimer’s Disease patients. Here, we will review the top 10 evidence-based uses for PBM, as supported by scientific research: Reduce inflammation: Red and NIR light have anti-inflammatory effects, and unlike anti-inflammatory medications (such as NSAID’s), do not cause side effects. Studies have found that PBM affects levels of many molecules involved in inflammation, including reactive oxygen species, reactive nitrogen species, and prostaglandins. The ability of PBM to reduce inflammation suggests that it could have therapeutic potential in many chronic diseases that involve inflammation, including arthritis, Alzheimer’s Disease, and depression. Improve skin health: Red/NIR lights are being widely used in spas and dermatology clinics for their effects on skin health, in addition to at-home use. As already mentioned, PBM can improve the appearance and healing of scars, and it is also helpful in the treatment of wrinkles, psoriasis, acne, rosacea, burns, and herpes. As well, PBM has been found to increase hair growth through stimulation of the hair follicle found in the dermis of the skin. Improvements in skin health are associated with increased collagen production in the dermis of the skin. Decrease pain: Pain creates a huge burden of disability, both personal and economic. There is evidence that PBM decreases many types of pain, including knee, neck, low-back, temporomandibular joint, and post-surgical pain. PBM can also reduce pain associated with arthritis and fibromyalgia. There are several mechanisms of pain reduction by PBM, including decreasing inflammation, decreasing oxidative stress, reducing the sensitivity of neurons, and decreasing the transmission of pain related nerve impulses. Improve athletic performance: PBM has been found to improve athletic performance in several ways, including decreasing muscle damage associated with exercise, decreasing muscle fatigue, improving muscle capacity, and speeding post-exercise recovery. PBM increases ATP production, which is needed for exercising muscles. PBM also helps muscles through increasing the synthesis of antioxidants, reducing inflammation, and decreasing synthesis of lactic acid (although not all studies have found this effect). Animal research has also shown that PBM can reduce muscle loss associated with trauma. Reduce depression and anxiety: Depression and anxiety are highly prevalent mental disorders, and currently available pharmaceutical medications have limited efficacy and associated side effects. PBM has been shown to reduce depressive symptoms in both humans and animals, likely due to improvements in mitochondrial function, increased brain blood flow, and decreased neuroinflammation. A 2009 clinical trial found a reduction in symptoms of depression and anxiety in as little as a single session of PBM. The effects of PBM on mental health are so compelling that a recent systematic review of PBM concluded that it is “strongly recommended” as a treatment for moderate depressive disorder and is “recommended” for the treatment of anxiety disorder. Studies of PBM and depression often apply PBM directly to the skull, while some use an intranasal approach. Improve cognitive function: PBM has been shown to improve cognitive function in both healthy and diseased patients. Clinical trials in healthy subjects have shown that PBM can improve outcomes including executive function, which consists of cognitive skills used for planning and performing tasks, as well as memory. People with traumatic brain injury (TBI) and stroke have also been shown to benefit from PBM, due to upregulation of brain repair mechanisms including the synthesis of new neurons. A recent systematic review similarly showed that PBM can help people with Alzheimer’s Disease by decreasing oxidative stress in the brain, reducing brain inflammation, and improving cognition. Speed healing from injury: It has already been mentioned that PBM has positive effects on muscle tissue, including speeding recovery from post-exercise damage, as well as on wound healing, such as from burn injuries. PBM can also speed healing from injuries to bone, including fractures and more complex bone injuries that require the use ceramic materials. Tendon injuries also benefit from PBM, with research showing that PBM increases the amount of collagen, which provides structural support during healing. Promote fat loss: A somewhat surprising effect of PBM is to promote fat loss. This is particularly true when combined with exercise. A study of obese women found that PBM combined with exercise resulted in a higher percentage of fat loss than when exercise was combined with a placebo light. Another study found similar results, along with changes in levels of a marker associated with increasing brown adipose tissue, which improves metabolism. When combined with treadmill training, PBM decreases the appearance of cellulite and increases metabolism in the thighs. In addition to effects on metabolism, PBM may also cause fat cells to release their contents into the blood, where they can be metabolized or excreted. Improve immune function: Although an in-depth investigation of how PBM affects the immune system specifically has yet to be done, there is strong evidence that PBM improves immune function, as evidenced by its beneficial effects in many immune-related disorders. For example, in Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (an autoimmune disease affecting the thyroid gland), PBM improved levels of thyroid hormones and decreased the need for medication, probably due to a reduction in inflammation. Similarly, in multiple sclerosis (an autoimmune disease affecting the nervous system), PBM increased the regeneration of nerve cells and decreased markers of inflammation. PBM also improves immune function and inflammation in the oral autoimmune disease oral lichen planus. It has even been shown to improve outcomes of COVID-19 infections, likely by reducing inflammation and improving immune function. The process of inflammation is controlled by the immune system, and many disorders (such as autoimmune diseases), involve an impaired immune response. Improve sleep: Light is a primary regulator of the body’s circadian rhythm, so it is not surprising that PBM has effects on sleep. Application of PBM during wakefulness improves sleep quality in people with cognitive decline, Guillain-Barré Syndrome, fibromyalgia and stroke. Interestingly, sleep duration decreased with full body PBM in elite athletes, while other parameters such as exercise recovery improved. When PBM is applied during sleep, there is an increased clearance of waste products from the brain and improved flow of cerebrospinal fluid, which are required for optimal brain health. So, PBM is beneficial when applied when either awake or sleeping, and the benefits relate more to improving sleep quality and physiology, rather than to increasing sleep duration. This list of uses for PBM is not exhaustive. Research exploring the use of PBM is expanding into many areas of health, with exciting results being seen in areas including hypertension, polycystic ovarian syndrome, eye health, and fertility, to name but a few. Truly, the range of applications of PBM for improving health is incredibly vast and can be explained by the cellular and molecular changes induced by light exposure. If you’re interested in buying a home PBM device, you have many options. When choosing a device, first look for a one that emits both red and NIR light. Second, look at the power of the device. While many high powered PBM units are available (usually at a higher price point), research shows that when it comes to light, more is not necessarily better. This is because PBM treatment to many tissues has a “biphasic” effect, where lower levels are beneficial while higher levels are not. But you don’t want to go too low, or you won’t get the treatment effect. Many of the cheaper devices on the market are underpowered and provide very little irradiation. At Fringe, our PBM devices were designed to mimic exposure to the sun, with consideration of the range of light exposure used in scientific research. Lastly, consider the type of device that is most appropriate for your condition. PBM devices come in panels and wearable forms such as wraps, with wearables providing more flexibility in terms of application and panels being better for general irradiation of larger surfaces. For more information about Fringe light products, go to: https://fringeheals.com/shop-all-products/
Learn more